We’ve already asked the biggest question about Denis V’s 2020 version of Dune: Do we really need it? Well now Youtube user Matt Skuta attempts to give an early answer by editing together a brilliant side-by-side trailer of the two films.

Early verdict? David Lynch’s film seems to hold up pretty well. But judge for yourself and check out the video below.

seagate hard drive ad

Cover images by Universal & Warner Bros. via